A reading club with a view to the future

332 Michael S. A. Graziano: Rethinking Consciousness

“Rethinking Consciousness” presents a scientific theory that aims to explain subjective experiences by examining how the brain constructs awareness.



In "Rethinking Consciousness," Michael S. A. Graziano challenges traditional notions of consciousness and offers a scientific theory to explain subjective experience. Graziano proposes the Attention Schema Theory (AST), which suggests that consciousness is not a mysterious phenomenon but rather a product of the brain's attention system. The book explores how the brain constructs awareness, including self-awareness, and addresses questions such as why we experience a vivid inner life and how we attribute awareness to others. Graziano delves into the scientific and philosophical implications of his theory, presenting a thought-provoking perspective on the nature of consciousness.


Title: "Rethinking Consciousness: A Scientific Theory of Subjective Experience"

Author: Michael S. A. Graziano

Publishing Year: 2019

Publisher: W. W. Norton & Company

Length in Hours: 6 hours 29 minutes

5 main ideas

  1. The Attention Schema Theory (AST) proposes that consciousness is an evolved system in the brain that generates models of attention and awareness.
  2. Consciousness is not a separate entity but a constructed model that the brain uses to understand and interact with the world.
  3. Awareness emerges from the brain's ability to create internal models and simulations, allowing us to anticipate and predict the behavior of ourselves and others.
  4. The brain attributes awareness to others based on behavioral cues and simulations of attention, leading to our social and empathetic interactions.
  5. Graziano argues that the scientific study of consciousness requires a shift in perspective from a mysterious and unexplainable phenomenon to an interdisciplinary exploration grounded in neuroscience and cognitive science.

5 funny quotes

  1. "Evolution... is a great practical joker."
  2. "The brain, like a teenager, doesn't always know what it's doing."
  3. "This theory takes the fun out of the supernatural."
  4. "The brain is a bit of a showoff."
  5. "The brain, it seems, has a small committee working diligently to drive philosophers mad."

5 thought-provoking quotes​

  1. "Consciousness is the brain's simplified, cartoonish model of attention."
  2. "The brain constructs an elaborate and utterly unnecessary model of awareness and then has no choice but to attribute it to itself."
  3. "Consciousness is not a fundamental property of the universe but a biological process."
  4. "We live in the cartoons that our brains draw for us."
  5. "The process of being aware is like a simplified model of attention being applied to a simplified model of the world."

5 dilemmas

  1. The Hard Problem of Consciousness: The dilemma of explaining subjective experience and how physical processes in the brain give rise to the rich phenomenological aspects of consciousness.
  2. The Illusion of Consciousness: The dilemma of reconciling the feeling of conscious awareness with the proposition that it is a constructed model created by the brain, rather than an inherent aspect of reality.
  3. The Ethics of Artificial Consciousness: The dilemma of exploring the potential development of conscious machines or artificial intelligence and the ethical implications of creating and interacting with entities that may possess subjective experience.
  4. The Role of Attention in Consciousness: The dilemma of understanding the relationship between attention and consciousness, and how attentional processes contribute to the construction of subjective awareness.
  5. The Boundaries of Consciousness: The dilemma of defining the limits of consciousness and determining what falls within the realm of conscious experience, including the possibility of unconscious processes influencing behavior and decision-making problem" of consciousness.

5 examples

  1. Albert Einstein is mentioned in the context of his quote: "The most incomprehensible thing about the world is that it is comprehensible," relating to the mysterious nature of consciousness.
  2. René Descartes, the philosopher known for his famous phrase "I think, therefore I am," is referenced in discussions on the nature of self-awareness and the mind-body problem.
  3. Charles Darwin is mentioned in relation to his evolutionary theory and its influence on understanding the origins and adaptive functions of consciousness.
  4. Sigmund Freud, the founder of psychoanalysis, is referenced in discussions on the interpretation of dreams and unconscious processes.
  5. Thomas Nagel, a philosopher known for his work on the subjective nature of conscious experience, is mentioned in relation to debates on the "hard Five interesting dilemmas from the book:

Referenced books

  1. "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" by Julian Jaynes
  2. "The Astonishing Hypothesis: The Scientific Search for the Soul" by Francis Crick
  3. "The Mind's I: Fantasies and Reflections on Self and Soul" edited by Douglas Hofstadter and Daniel Dennett
  4. "The Ego Tunnel: The Science of the Mind and the Myth of the Self" by Thomas Metzinger
  5. "Consciousness Explained" by Daniel C. Dennett

Share a quote

"The brain, like a teenager, doesn't always know what it's doing."

Become a NextBook Insider

Join our community to access exclusive content, comment on stories, participate in giveaways, and more.