A reading club with a view to the future

359 Peter Godfrey-Smith: Metazoa

“Metazoa” explores the origins and nature of animal consciousness, tracing the evolutionary journey of animals and delving into the complex relationship between minds and bodies. It delves into the fascinating world of animal cognition, emotions, and social behavior, offering insights into the origins of the human mind.



In "Metazoa," Godfrey-Smith takes readers on a captivating journey through the animal kingdom, investigating the origins and development of consciousness. From primitive organisms to the sophisticated minds of mammals, the book explores the intricate connections between biology, evolution, and the emergence of minds. It delves into the fascinating behaviors and cognitive abilities of various animal species, shedding light on the fundamental nature of consciousness and its evolutionary significance.


Title: "Metazoa: Animal Life and the Birth of the Mind"

Author: Peter Godfrey-Smith

Publishing Year: 2020

Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux

Length in Hours: 9 hours and 49 minutes

5 main ideas

  1. Evolution of Animal Life: The book examines the evolutionary history of animals, from the simplest multicellular organisms to the diverse and complex forms we see today, uncovering the key milestones and adaptations that shaped animal life.
  2. Animal Minds and Consciousness: Godfrey-Smith explores the nature of animal consciousness, discussing the cognitive abilities, emotions, and social behaviors of different species and offering insights into the similarities and differences between human and animal minds.
  3. Symbiosis and Cooperation: The author investigates the role of symbiotic relationships and cooperative behaviors in the evolution of animals, highlighting the interconnectedness and interdependence of different species.
  4. Sensory Perception and Communication: The book explores the diverse sensory modalities used by animals and the ways they communicate, from chemical signals to complex vocalizations, shedding light on the richness and complexity of animal perception.
  5. Ethical Implications: Godfrey-Smith addresses the ethical considerations that arise from our understanding of animal minds, encouraging readers to reflect on our treatment of animals and the moral responsibilities that come with recognizing their capacities for consciousness and sentience.

5 funny quotes

  1. "In the animal kingdom, minds come in all shapes and sizes, from the microscopic to the magnificent, proving that brains are not a prerequisite for intelligence."
  2. "Who needs language when you have a repertoire of dances, songs, and gestures? Animals have their own vibrant ways of communicating and expressing themselves."
  3. "It turns out that animals are natural-born problem solvers, using creative strategies to navigate their environments and find hidden treasures."
  4. "Some animals have mastered the art of camouflage so well that they could give professional hide-and-seek players a run for their money."
  5. "Animals have mastered the fine art of body language, using wagging tails, flapping wings, and expressive postures to communicate everything from affection to aggression."

5 thought-provoking quotes​

  1. "Animal consciousness offers a window into the evolution of minds and the exploration of what it means to be aware, sentient, and connected to the world."
  2. "The study of animal minds challenges our preconceived notions of intelligence and highlights the remarkable cognitive abilities exhibited by creatures we often underestimate."
  3. "Animals not only respond to their environment but actively engage with it, displaying problem-solving skills, social interactions, and even forms of cultural learning."
  4. "The boundaries between human and animal minds are not as distinct as we once believed, blurring the line between what is uniquely human and what is shared by other sentient beings."
  5. "Understanding the complexities of animal consciousness compels us to reevaluate our ethical responsibilities and reframe our relationship with the natural world."

5 dilemmas

  1. The Measurement of Animal Consciousness: How do we assess and measure the subjective experiences and consciousness of animals, considering their diverse cognitive abilities and the limitations of our human-centric perspective?
  2. Animal Welfare and Ethics: How should our understanding of animal consciousness and emotions shape our ethical considerations and treatment of animals in various contexts, including farming, research, and conservation?
  3. Human-Animal Relationships: How can we cultivate more meaningful and respectful relationships with animals, considering their capacities for consciousness, emotions, and social interactions?
  4. Cultural Variations in Animal Minds: To what extent do cultural factors shape the cognitive abilities and behaviors of animals, and how does this influence our understanding of animal minds across different species?
  5. Extending Rights to Animals: Should certain animals be granted legal rights and protections based on their capacities for consciousness and sentience, and how might this reshape our legal and moral frameworks?

5 examples

  1. Jane Goodall: The book discusses Jane Goodall's groundbreaking research on chimpanzees, highlighting her observations of their complex social structures and intelligent behaviors.
  2. Konrad Lorenz: Godfrey-Smith explores Konrad Lorenz's pioneering work on imprinting in birds, revealing how early experiences shape their behavior and social interactions.
  3. Charles Darwin: The author delves into Charles Darwin's theories of evolution and natural selection, examining their implications for understanding the origins and development of animal minds.
  4. Temple Grandin: "Metazoa" explores the unique perspective of Temple Grandin, an advocate for animal welfare who revolutionized the livestock industry by designing more humane handling systems based on her understanding of animal behavior.
  5. Carl Sagan: Godfrey-Smith draws inspiration from Carl Sagan's exploration of extraterrestrial life and the potential for non-human intelligences, reflecting on the mysteries of consciousness beyond our own planet.

Referenced books

  1. "The Inner Life of Animals: Love, Grief, and Compassion—Surprising Observations of a Hidden World" by Peter Wohlleben
  2. "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" by Julian Jaynes
  3. "Beyond Words: What Animals Think and Feel" by Carl Safina
  4. "Are We Smart Enough to Know How Smart Animals Are?" by Frans de Waal
  5. "The Extended Mind: The Power of Thinking Outside the Brain" by Annie Murphy Paul

Share a quote

"Who needs language when you have a repertoire of dances, songs, and gestures? Animals have their own vibrant ways of communicating and expressing themselves."

Become a NextBook Insider

Join our community to access exclusive content, comment on stories, participate in giveaways, and more.