A reading club with a view to the future

360 Peter Godfrey-Smith: Other Minds

“Other Minds” explores the fascinating world of octopuses and their remarkable cognitive abilities, providing insights into the nature of consciousness and the evolution of minds. It delves into the mysterious and alien world of these intelligent creatures, challenging our understanding of consciousness and highlighting the diverse forms it can take.



In "Other Minds," Peter Godfrey-Smith takes readers on a captivating journey into the depths of the ocean to explore the enigmatic world of octopuses. Drawing on his own observations and scientific research, he uncovers the astonishing cognitive abilities of these creatures and reflects on the nature of consciousness itself. The book delves into the complex behaviors, problem-solving skills, and interactions of octopuses, providing a unique perspective on the origins and diversity of conscious experience.


Title: "Other Minds: The Octopus, the Sea, and the Deep Origins of Consciousness"

Author: Peter Godfrey-Smith

Publishing Year: 2016

Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux

Length in Hours: 7 hours and 4 minutes

5 main ideas

  1. The Octopus Mind: Godfrey-Smith delves into the fascinating world of octopuses, exploring their unique biology, behaviors, and evolutionary history. He investigates the neural basis of their intelligence and the ways in which their decentralized nervous systems contribute to their cognitive abilities.
  2. Evolutionary Convergence: The book discusses the concept of evolutionary convergence, highlighting the striking similarities between the cognitive capabilities of octopuses and those of humans. It examines the convergence of minds across different branches of the tree of life and its implications for understanding the origins of consciousness.
  3. The Nature of Consciousness: Godfrey-Smith explores different theories of consciousness and reflects on how the study of octopuses challenges our understanding of this complex phenomenon. He examines the similarities and differences between human and octopus consciousness and considers the implications for our broader understanding of minds.
  4. Social Interactions: The author investigates the social behaviors of octopuses, highlighting their ability to communicate, recognize individuals, and engage in complex interactions. He explores the social dynamics within octopus communities and how these behaviors shed light on the nature of intelligence and social cognition.
  5. Conservation and Ethics: "Other Minds" addresses the importance of octopus conservation and ethical considerations surrounding the treatment of these intelligent creatures. It raises awareness of the challenges they face in their natural habitats 

5 funny quotes

  1. "Octopuses are the true masters of multitasking, with eight arms to juggle their daily endeavors."
  2. "If there were an Olympic Games for camouflage, octopuses would win the gold medal every time."
  3. "Octopuses have a knack for escape artistry that would put Houdini to shame. Their agility and problem-solving skills make them the Houdinis of the ocean."
  4. "Octopuses have a flair for the dramatic, employing mesmerizing displays of color and shape-shifting to communicate and confuse their prey."
  5. "When it comes to problem-solving, octopuses are the MacGyvers of the sea, using their wits and flexible bodies to overcome challenges."

5 thought-provoking quotes​

  1. "In the depths of the ocean, a separate experiment in the evolution of intelligence has been unfolding for millions of years, with the octopus as its primary subject."
  2. "Octopuses challenge our understanding of intelligence and consciousness, revealing the vast diversity of possible minds in the natural world."
  3. "Through their complex behaviors and problem-solving skills, octopuses demonstrate that intelligence can arise in forms radically different from our own."
  4. "The octopus, an alien consciousness, offers a glimpse into the mysteries of the mind and the rich tapestry of consciousness in the animal kingdom."
  5. "Studying octopuses teaches us humility and forces us to confront the limits of our understanding, inviting us to expand our notion of what it means to be conscious."

5 dilemmas

  1. The Nature of Consciousness: How can we define and understand consciousness beyond the human experience, considering the diversity of minds in the animal kingdom?
  2. Alien Intelligences: What can we learn from the intelligence and behavior of octopuses about the possibilities of intelligence and consciousness in radically different forms?
  3. Ethical Considerations: How should our growing understanding of octopus intelligence and consciousness shape our ethical treatment of these creatures and our responsibilities as stewards of the marine environment?
  4. Conservation Challenges: What are the unique conservation challenges faced by octopuses and other marine creatures, and how can we protect their habitats and ensure their survival?
  5. Evolutionary Convergence: How does the convergence of minds across different branches of the tree of life provide insights into the origins and evolution of consciousness, and what does it reveal about the underlying principles of intelligence?

5 examples

  1. David Attenborough: Godfrey-Smith draws on the insights and observations of renowned naturalist David Attenborough, who has documented the wonders of the natural world, including the intelligence and behaviors of octopuses.
  2. Sylvia Earle: The author discusses the pioneering work of oceanographer Sylvia Earle, who has explored the depths of the ocean and raised awareness about the importance of marine conservation, including the preservation of octopus habitats.
  3. Aristotle: Godfrey-Smith references the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle, who was among the first to study marine life and ponder the nature of consciousness in animals, including the cephalopods.
  4. Carl Sagan: The book draws inspiration from the renowned scientist Carl Sagan, who explored the possibilities of extraterrestrial life and contemplated the diversity of minds that could exist beyond Earth.
  5. Jacques Cousteau: The author acknowledges the contributions of Jacques Cousteau, the renowned oceanographer and explorer who introduced the world to the wonders of the underwater realm and fostered curiosity about marine life.


Referenced books

  1. "The Soul of an Octopus: A Surprising Exploration into the Wonder of Consciousness" by Sy Montgomery
  2. "Octopus!: The Most Mysterious Creature in the Sea" by Katherine Harmon Courage
  3. "The Octopus: A Story of California" by Frank Norris
  4. "Cephalopod Cognition" edited by Anne-Sophie Darmaillacq, Ludovic Dickel, and Jennifer Mather
  5. "The Octopus and the Orangutan: New Tales of Animal Intrigue, Intelligence, and Ingenuity" by Eugene Linden

Share a quote

"If there were an Olympic Games for camouflage, octopuses would win the gold medal every time."

Become a NextBook Insider

Join our community to access exclusive content, comment on stories, participate in giveaways, and more.